I understand completely!!!! I moved my entire collection from Illinois to Wisconsin. Then from WI to Virginia. Then from Virginia back to Wisconsin. Then from the Wisconsin apartment to our new house where it all sits in a pile of crates in the basement as I type right now. Each of these moves was about 1.5 years apart.
So... I've been there and I thought the same thing each time.
All I can say is ... it's worth it. Well, it was to me anyway. You have to ask yourself how important it is to you. Are you going to be moving a lot, or are you staying where you're going for quite some time? If you're in the military or something, then probably go emulation, but if this is a permanent move, I'd just move it and keep it.
You're probably also stressing out about it all getting damaged in the move. At least, I did. If so, just pack everything decently, tape all the crates shut, then load them all top load in the truck as much as possible so they don't get crushed by heavy things, then strap every few rows of crates in so they don't shift much. Pack smart and everything will be fine. Mine was all fine (I unpacked everything then repacked to move again this time).
That's all I can really say. A bigger issue for me was moving dozens of boxes of books (I have a book problem). Books are flippin' heavy, wow. I did get rid of a lot of books, but nothing significant in terms of retro gaming stuff.
The CRT's, I don't know. I have a few Commodore monitors for everything, I moved those. And one 22" CRT TV. So, it's a tough call on those. I'm not so picky about what they're displayed on though.
If the retro stuff is important to you, I think you'd regret letting it all go though. They're not making the stuff anymore, and it's all getting harder to find. Easier to move it now than replace it later.
Let us know how it goes.
EDIT: I just read fiddlepaddle's post... I've changed in the same ways. I now regularly pass on gaming stuff in thrifts if it's not something I really want to play or need to fill a hole. I don't collect doubles (leave them for the next guy who may not have them), don't buy broken stuff, pass broken/parts stuff on to others who can use them, and I'm even thinking of getting rid of some stuff that isn't that meaningful to me (e.g. am I ever really going to have a large NES collection? No, so why do I have 40-50 random NES carts? No reason.) All those self-imposed rules really does help get your collection under control for the future. In other words, focus as you go on and then it won't seem so out of control and pointless.
Edited by Mirage1972, Fri Nov 20, 2009 11:56 PM.